See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (2025)

Though sometimes it seems nearly impossible to keep up with the sheer volume of must-watch TV shows hitting the streaming networks and beyond, PEOPLE readers appear to have no issues maintaining that breakneck pace, as you have cast your votes loudly and proudly for your small screen faves.

From your favorite Saturday Night Live hottie to the Sexiest Man on Bravo to your favorite medical procedural to the person you want to take over Hoda Kotb's spot next to Jenna Bush, readers took to PEOPLE's TV Poll and the votes are in!

See who won PEOPLE's TV Poll, featuring your current TV obsessions.

01of 13

Best 'SNL' Hottie: Colin Jost

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (1)

Who doesn't love a funny guy? In a category that featured his colleagues Michael Che, Marcello Hernandez and Bowen Yang, Colin Jost came out on top. Could it be that cutting humor? The laidback, no pressure delivery? That charming laugh? One thing's for sure: PEOPLE readers (and his wife Scarlett Johansson) find his face anything but punchable.

02of 13

Sexiest TV Cop: Eric Winter

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (2)

Sergeant Tim Bradford is the type of sexy where someone might find themselves purposefully causing a scene, just so he can show up and save the day. The man who portrays The Rookie character is, of course, Eric Winter, whom readers voted as the sexiest TV cop. He beat out other siren-worthy hotties Daniel Sunjata, Shemar Moore and LaRoyce Hawkins.

03of 13

Best Comedy: 'Abbott Elementary'

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (3)

With an assortment of captivating quirky characters, it's no wonder Abbott Elementary snagged the top spot when it came to "Best Comedy." It seems the writers of the show have truly hit their stride, as each episode leaves us wanting more. Of course, Happy's Place, Man on the Inside and Sex Lives of College Girls are also bringing the funny in major ways.

04of 13

Sexiest Comeback Star: Joshua Jackson

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (4)

Nostalgia for Joshua Jackson from his Dawson's Creek days is incredibly strong, landing him the title of "Sexiest Comeback Star" for his role on Doctor Odyssey. The category had strong contenders in Noah Wyle (from ER to The Pitt), Damon Wayans Sr. (In Living Color to Poppa's House) and Scott Wolf (Party of Five to Doc), but Jackson cruised (Doctor Odyssey joke) to victory.

05of 13

Show You Want to Compete On: 'Jeopardy!'

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (5)

Everyone on the planet apparently has the same fantasy: To appear on Jeopardy! and sweep entire categories, navigating Daily Doubles with ease. Readers selected the trivia show as the top choice for a competition show they would want to appear on, beating out Deal or No Deal Island, Survivor and The Bachelor.

06of 13

Best Scripted Returning Show: 'Reacher'

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (6)

Hot guy + kicking ass + seeking justice = must-watch TV. It's a formula that has been tried and true and continues to find success in Reacher, the Prime Video action drama starring Alan Ritchson, Willa Fitzgerald, Kristen Kreuk, Serinda Swan and more. Other contenders for "Best Scripted Returning Show" included 1923, The White Lotus and Yellowjackets.

07of 13

Sexiest Man on Bravo: Jason Chambers

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (7)

The cast of Below Deck Down Under fawns over Captain Chambers' undeniable good looks — and guess what? So do you all. The charming Aussie was voted the Sexiest Man on Bravo, beating out Andy Cohen, Southern Charm's Craig Conover, and Summer House's Jesse Solomon.

08of 13

Best Returning Reality Show: 'Love Is Blind'

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (8)

The dating show that aims to match singles with the loves of their life, "sight unseen," is also the show that PEOPLE readers can't take their eyes off of. The Netflix show came out victorious in a category that featured equally bingeworthy reality fare including The Bachelor, Summer House and Below Deck Down Under.

09of 13

Who Should Cohost with Jenna Bush Hager? Keke Palmer

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (9)

While Andy Cohen, Justin Sylvester and Zuri Hall would make great hosts, the people voted for our girl Keke Palmer as the best suited to take the seat next to Jenna Bush Hager on Today . She's meme-worthy, she's hip to all the internet chatter and she's never shy about sharing her opinion, so we think she's a pretty impeccable candidate.

10of 13

Best Reality TV Host: Jeff Probst

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (10)

Given the fact that Jeff Probst has been the sole host of Survivor since its inception back in 2000, it's no wonder he was picked as the "Best Reality TV Host." Traitors' Alan Cumming, The Challenge's T.J. Lavin and Deal or No Deal Island's Joe Manganiello were the other gents in the hard-fought category.

11of 13

Best Dressed Traitor: Ciara Miller

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (11)

She may have been banished out of the castle, but Ciara Miller never fails to serve a look and viewers have taken note. The Traitors star and Summer House alum won "Best Dressed" over Bob Harper, Bob the Drag Queen and Chrishell Stause.

12of 13

Best Medical Drama: 'The Pitt'

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (12)

Two words: Noah Wyle. And we're not saying readers are tuning into this gripping medical drama just to see the ER alum back in scrubs ... but that nostalgic feeling of watching him barrel a gurney through a set of double doors to go save a life just never gets old, does it? Brilliant Minds, Doc and Watson were the other shows in this category.

13of 13

Sexiest Man on a Scripted Show: Morris Chestnut

See Who Won PEOPLE's Readers' Choice TV Poll — Fair Warning, You May Get Heated at the Results (13)

Oh, Morris. He is tall, dark and handsome, he has a smolder that can make anyone weak in the knees and he is bringing it all plus his sharp acting chops to his titular role on CBS' Watson. In a category with Bryan Greenberg, Leo Woodhall and Sang Heon Lee we're not saying this was an easy choice, but we certainly see the vision.